How do palliative care doctors recognise imminently dying patients? A judgement analysis

File Description SizeFormat 
e024996.full.pdfPublished version1.08 MBAdobe PDFView/Open
Title: How do palliative care doctors recognise imminently dying patients? A judgement analysis
Authors: White, N
Harries, P
Harris, AJL
Vickerstaff, V
Lodge, P
McGowan, C
Minton, O
Tomlinson, C
Tookman, A
Reid, F
Stone, P
Item Type: Journal Article
Abstract: Objectives To identify a group of palliative care doctors who perform well on a prognostic test and to understand how they make their survival predictions. Design Prospective observational study and two cross-sectional online studies. Setting Phase I: an online prognostic test, developed from a prospective observational study of patients referred to palliative care. Phase II: an online judgement task consisting of 50 hypothetical vignettes. Participants All members of the Association of Palliative Medicine (APM) were eligible (n=~1100). 99 doctors completed the prognostic test and were included in the phase I analysis. The top 20% were invited to participate in phase II; 14/19 doctors completed the judgement task and were included in the phase II analysis. Measures Phase I: participants were asked to give a probability of death within 72 hours (0%–100%) for all 20 cases. Accuracy on the prognostic test was measured with the Brier score which was used to identify the ‘expert’ group (scale range: 0 (expert)–1 (non-expert)). Phase II: participants gave a probability of death within 72 hours (0%–100%). A mixed model regression analysis was completed using the percentage estimate as the outcome and the patient information included in the vignettes as the predictors. Results The mean Brier score of all participants was 0.237 (95% CI 0.235 to 0.239). The mean Brier score of the ‘experts’ was 0.184 (95% CI 0.176 to 0.192). Six of the seven prognostic variables included in the hypothetical vignettes were significantly associated with clinician predictions of death. The Palliative Performance Score was identified as being the most influential in the doctors’ prognostic decision making (β=0.48, p<0.001). Conclusions This study identified six clinical signs and symptoms which influenced the judgement policies of palliative care doctors. These results may be used to teach novice doctors how to improve their prognostic skills.
Issue Date: 30-Nov-2018
Date of Acceptance: 19-Oct-2018
ISSN: 2044-6055
Publisher: BMJ
Journal / Book Title: BMJ Open
Volume: 8
Issue: 11
Copyright Statement: © 2018 The Author(s). This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See:
Publication Status: Published
Article Number: e024996
Online Publication Date: 2018-11-25
Appears in Collections:Division of Surgery
Faculty of Natural Sciences

Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.

Creative Commonsx