SimiVal, a Multi-Criteria Map Comparison Tool for Land-Change Model Projections
File(s)Simival_CD_final.pdf (1.53 MB) SupInf.pdf (328.63 KB)
Accepted version
Supporting information
Author(s)
Type
Journal Article
Abstract
The multiple uses of land-cover models have led to validation with choice metrics or an ad
hoc choice of the validation metrics available. To address this, we have identified the major
dimensions of land-cover maps that ought to be evaluated and devised a Similarity
Validation (SimiVal) tool. SimiVal uses a linear regression to test a modelled projection
against benchmark cases of, perfect, observed and systematic-bias, calculated by rescaling
the metrics from a random case relative to the observed, perfect case. The most informative
regression coefficients, p-value and slope, are plot on a ternary graph of ‘similarity space’
whose extremes are the three benchmark cases. This plot provides a rigorous similarity
assessment against these extremes and other projections. SimiVal is tested on projections
of two deliberately contrasting land-cover models to show the similarity between intra- and
inter-model parameterisations. Predictive and exploratory models can benefit from the tool.
hoc choice of the validation metrics available. To address this, we have identified the major
dimensions of land-cover maps that ought to be evaluated and devised a Similarity
Validation (SimiVal) tool. SimiVal uses a linear regression to test a modelled projection
against benchmark cases of, perfect, observed and systematic-bias, calculated by rescaling
the metrics from a random case relative to the observed, perfect case. The most informative
regression coefficients, p-value and slope, are plot on a ternary graph of ‘similarity space’
whose extremes are the three benchmark cases. This plot provides a rigorous similarity
assessment against these extremes and other projections. SimiVal is tested on projections
of two deliberately contrasting land-cover models to show the similarity between intra- and
inter-model parameterisations. Predictive and exploratory models can benefit from the tool.
Date Issued
2016-05-11
Date Acceptance
2016-04-15
Citation
Environmental Modelling and Software, 2016, 82, pp.229-240
ISSN
1873-6726
Publisher
Elsevier
Start Page
229
End Page
240
Journal / Book Title
Environmental Modelling and Software
Volume
82
Copyright Statement
© 2016, Elsevier. Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Sponsor
Commission of the European Communities
Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)
Grant Number
281986
Subjects
Environmental Engineering
MD Multidisciplinary
Publication Status
Published