Comment on time-variation of fundamental constants
File(s)0208093v4.pdf (147.46 KB)
Working paper
Author(s)
Duff,M.J.
Type
Working Paper
Abstract
The possible time variation of dimensionless fundamental constants of nature, such as the fine-structure constant α, is a legitimate subject of physical enquiry. By contrast, the time variation of dimensional constants, such as ℏ, c, G, e, k,... which are merely human constructs whose number and values differ from one choice of units to the next, has no operational meaning. To illustrate this, we refute a recent claim of Davies et al that black holes can discriminate between two contending theories of varying α, one with varying c and the other with varying e. In Appendix A we respond to criticisms by P. Davies and two Nature referees. In Appendix B we respond to remarks by Magueijo and by T. Davis. In Appendix C we critique recent claims by Copi, A. Davis and Krauss to have placed constraints on ΔG/G.} In Appendix D we provide extracts of a lecture by Dirac, of which we have only recently become aware, which includes the comment "Talking about whether a thing is constant or not does not have any absolute meaning unless that quantity is dimensionless".
Date Issued
2016-11-30
Citation
2016
Publisher
arXiv
Copyright Statement
© 2019 The Authors.
Identifier
http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0208093
Subjects
hep-th
hep-th
astro-ph
gr-qc
hep-ph
Publication Status
Published