Potential health impacts of residential exposures to extremely low frequency magnetic fields in Europe
File(s)1-s2.0-S0160412013002110-main.pdf (541.45 KB)
Published version
Author(s)
Grellier, J
Ravazzani, P
Cardis, E
Type
Journal Article
Abstract
Over the last two decades residential exposure to extremely low frequency magnetic fields (ELF MF) has been associated with childhood leukaemia relatively consistently in epidemiological studies, though causality is still under investigation.
We aimed to estimate the cases of childhood leukaemia that might be attributable to exposure to ELF MF in the European Union (EU27), if the associations seen in epidemiological studies were causal.
We estimated distributions of ELF MF exposure using studies identified in the existing literature. Individual distributions of exposure were integrated using a probabilistic mixture distribution approach. Exposure–response functions were estimated from the most recently published pooled analysis of epidemiological data. Probabilistic simulation was used to estimate population attributable fractions (AFP) and attributable cases of childhood leukaemia in the EU27.
By assigning the literature review-based exposure distribution to all EU27 countries, we estimated the total annual number of cases of leukaemia attributable to ELF MF at between ~ 50 (95% CIs: − 14, 132) and ~ 60 (95% CIs: − 9, 610), depending on whether exposure–response was modelled categorically or continuously, respectively, for a non-threshold effect. This corresponds to between ~ 1.5% and ~ 2.0% of all incident cases of childhood leukaemia occurring annually in the EU27. Considerable uncertainties are due to scarce data on exposure and the choice of exposure–response model, demonstrating the importance of further research into better understanding mechanisms of the potential association between ELF MF exposure and childhood leukaemia and the need for improved monitoring of residential exposures to ELF MF in Europe.
We aimed to estimate the cases of childhood leukaemia that might be attributable to exposure to ELF MF in the European Union (EU27), if the associations seen in epidemiological studies were causal.
We estimated distributions of ELF MF exposure using studies identified in the existing literature. Individual distributions of exposure were integrated using a probabilistic mixture distribution approach. Exposure–response functions were estimated from the most recently published pooled analysis of epidemiological data. Probabilistic simulation was used to estimate population attributable fractions (AFP) and attributable cases of childhood leukaemia in the EU27.
By assigning the literature review-based exposure distribution to all EU27 countries, we estimated the total annual number of cases of leukaemia attributable to ELF MF at between ~ 50 (95% CIs: − 14, 132) and ~ 60 (95% CIs: − 9, 610), depending on whether exposure–response was modelled categorically or continuously, respectively, for a non-threshold effect. This corresponds to between ~ 1.5% and ~ 2.0% of all incident cases of childhood leukaemia occurring annually in the EU27. Considerable uncertainties are due to scarce data on exposure and the choice of exposure–response model, demonstrating the importance of further research into better understanding mechanisms of the potential association between ELF MF exposure and childhood leukaemia and the need for improved monitoring of residential exposures to ELF MF in Europe.
Date Issued
2013-10-24
Date Acceptance
2013-09-25
Citation
Environment International, 2013, 62, pp.55-63
ISSN
1873-6750
Publisher
Elsevier
Start Page
55
End Page
63
Journal / Book Title
Environment International
Volume
62
Copyright Statement
Open access under CC BY-NC-SA license
Subjects
Science & Technology
Life Sciences & Biomedicine
Environmental Sciences
Environmental Sciences & Ecology
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES
Cancer
Childhood leukaemia
Electromagnetic fields
Low frequency
Magnetic fields
Risk assessment
DOSE-RESPONSE DATA
ELECTROMAGNETIC-FIELDS
CHILDHOOD LEUKEMIA
POOLED ANALYSIS
TRANSFORMER STATIONS
POWER-LINES
ENVIRONMENTAL CARCINOGENS
ATTRIBUTABLE FRACTIONS
TREND ESTIMATION
POPULATION
Child
Environmental Exposure
Epidemiologic Studies
Europe
Humans
Leukemia
Magnetic Fields
MD Multidisciplinary
Publication Status
Published