The interindividual variability in the neural drive sent from the spinal cord to muscles is largely unknown, even during highly constrained motor tasks. Here, we investigated individual differences in the strength of neural drive received by the vastus lateralis (VL) and vastus medialis (VM) during an isometric task. We also assessed the proportion of common neural drive within and between these muscles. Twenty-two participants performed a series of submaximal isometric knee extensions at 25% of their peak torque. High-density surface electromyography recordings were decomposed into motor unit action potentials. Coherence analyses were applied on the motor unit spike trains to assess the degree of neural drive that was shared between motor neurons. Six participants were retested ∼20 mo after the first session. The distribution of the strength of neural drive between VL and VM varied between participants and was correlated with the distribution of normalized interference electromyography (EMG) signals (r > 0.56). The level of within- and between-muscle coherence varied across individuals, with a significant positive correlation between these two outcomes (VL: r = 0.48; VM: r = 0.58). We also observed a large interindividual variability in the proportion of muscle-specific drive, that is, the drive unique to each muscle (VL range: 6%-83%, VM range: 6%-86%). All the outcome measures were robust across sessions, providing evidence that the individual differences did not depend solely on the variability of the measures. Together, these results demonstrate that the neural strategies to control the VL and VM muscles widely vary across individuals, even during a constrained task.NEW & NOTEWORTHY We observed that the distribution of the strength of neural drive between the vastus lateralis and vastus medialis during a single-joint isometric task varied across participants. Also, we observed that the proportion of neural drive that was shared within and between these muscles also varied across participants. These results provide evidence that the neural strategies to control the vastus lateralis and vastus medialis muscles widely vary across individuals, even during a mechanically constrained task.