Recurrence following varicocelectomy is an important cause of treatment failure and persistence of subnormal semen parameters. This original study was combined with a systemic review and meta-analysis aiming to evaluate the efficacy of redo varicocelectomy on male fertility potential and pregnancy outcome. The retrospective study included 32 patients who underwent microsurgical subinguinal varicocelectomy for patients with recurrent varicocele. Changes in semen parameters and hormone profiles before and after surgery were compared. The literature review followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses and included seven articles in addition to our original report. Results of the original study revealed statistically significant improvements in sperm concentration, progressive motility, total motile sperm count and normal morphology following redo varicocelectomy. The meta-analysis results echoed those reported in our original study and depicted significant improvements in sperm concentration (mean difference [MD] = +20.281 million/ml, p < 0.001), total motility (MD = +9.659%, p = 0.001), total motile sperm count (MD = +23.258 million sperm, p < 0.001) and normal morphology (MD = +4.460%, p < 0.001). Overall pregnancy outcome was reported in seven studies with a rate of 34.6%. No significant changes were noted in any of the collected hormone results both in this original report and in the meta-analysis. In conclusion, redo varicocelectomy has a beneficial role on male fertility potential and can be offered for men with recurrent varicocele as directed by their individual clinical condition.