Using routine data to evaluate real-world public health interventions – assessing the reach, impact, and fidelity of The Daily Mile
File(s)
Author(s)
Venkatraman, Tishya
Type
Thesis
Abstract
Background
Public health interventions are often promoted without strong evidence of effectiveness in real-world settings. In England there is a vast amount of routine data available that can be used to evaluate these interventions. Less than 50% of children in England meet the government’s physical activity guidelines, which is a major public health concern. Simple, effective interventions for all are required to tackle shortfalls in children’s physical activity. The Daily Mile (TDM) is a school-based active mile intervention that has been widely adopted to address this shortfall. This thesis aims to use routine data to evaluate a real-world public health intervention by assessing the reach, impact, and fidelity of TDM.
Methods
This thesis comprises four cross-sectional studies linking various health, education, and census data. In the first study, I created a database of all state-funded primary schools in England and used multilevel models to determine the association between school and local authority characteristics, and registration to TDM. In the second study, I conducted a hierarchical cluster analysis to group local authorities by ‘need’ and estimated the association between ‘need’ and registration to TDM. In the third study, I used self-reported physical activity data to compare minutes of MVPA, and the variety of activities reported per week between children attending TDM-registered and non-TDM registered schools. Finally, I assessed fidelity to TDM’s core running criteria among children registered using descriptive statistics and multilevel models.
Results
TDM is a wide-reaching intervention with one in five primary schools in England registered. Schools in urban areas and schools with a higher proportion of disadvantaged pupils were more likely to register. TDM appears to be an equitable intervention reaching schools in areas of highest need; registration ranged from one in five schools in low-need areas to one in four in high-need areas. Children attending schools registered to TDM reported a marginally greater variety of activity and 10 additional minutes of MVPA/week during school hours and 26 additional minutes of MVPA/week outside school hours compared to children in non-TDM schools. Fidelity of implementation to TDM remained low, where 30% of those registered reported adhering to TDM’s core running criteria.
Conclusion
This thesis demonstrates that routine data can effectively be used to evaluate real-world public health interventions. TDM is a wide-reaching intervention and appears to be equitable. However, it does not seem to impact children’s physical activity substantially, and implementation remains low. TDM must be embedded within a broader suite of interventions to increase children’s physical activity.
Public health interventions are often promoted without strong evidence of effectiveness in real-world settings. In England there is a vast amount of routine data available that can be used to evaluate these interventions. Less than 50% of children in England meet the government’s physical activity guidelines, which is a major public health concern. Simple, effective interventions for all are required to tackle shortfalls in children’s physical activity. The Daily Mile (TDM) is a school-based active mile intervention that has been widely adopted to address this shortfall. This thesis aims to use routine data to evaluate a real-world public health intervention by assessing the reach, impact, and fidelity of TDM.
Methods
This thesis comprises four cross-sectional studies linking various health, education, and census data. In the first study, I created a database of all state-funded primary schools in England and used multilevel models to determine the association between school and local authority characteristics, and registration to TDM. In the second study, I conducted a hierarchical cluster analysis to group local authorities by ‘need’ and estimated the association between ‘need’ and registration to TDM. In the third study, I used self-reported physical activity data to compare minutes of MVPA, and the variety of activities reported per week between children attending TDM-registered and non-TDM registered schools. Finally, I assessed fidelity to TDM’s core running criteria among children registered using descriptive statistics and multilevel models.
Results
TDM is a wide-reaching intervention with one in five primary schools in England registered. Schools in urban areas and schools with a higher proportion of disadvantaged pupils were more likely to register. TDM appears to be an equitable intervention reaching schools in areas of highest need; registration ranged from one in five schools in low-need areas to one in four in high-need areas. Children attending schools registered to TDM reported a marginally greater variety of activity and 10 additional minutes of MVPA/week during school hours and 26 additional minutes of MVPA/week outside school hours compared to children in non-TDM schools. Fidelity of implementation to TDM remained low, where 30% of those registered reported adhering to TDM’s core running criteria.
Conclusion
This thesis demonstrates that routine data can effectively be used to evaluate real-world public health interventions. TDM is a wide-reaching intervention and appears to be equitable. However, it does not seem to impact children’s physical activity substantially, and implementation remains low. TDM must be embedded within a broader suite of interventions to increase children’s physical activity.
Version
Open Access
Date Issued
2021-08
Date Awarded
2022-02
Copyright Statement
Creative Commons Attribution NonCommercial Licence
License URL
Advisor
Saxena, Sonia
Costelloe, Ceire
Sponsor
National Institute for Health Research (Great Britain)
Grant Number
PD-SPH-2015-10055)
Publisher Department
Department of Primary Care and Public Health
Publisher Institution
Imperial College London
Qualification Level
Doctoral
Qualification Name
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)